This article in U.S. News offers six strategies geared to the new SAT policy that allows students to hide scores of certain SAT results and only present to colleges the ones the students would like them to see (presumably the highest of the bunch).
Some of the ideas are solid and ones that I have preached for years — start early and practice regularly and often. Other advice I like a lot less. I do not think taking the test ten times is a good idea just because a student can hide scores. As the SAT knows well, without intervening help at improving the skills tested on the SAT, repeat testing is not going to result in more than a gross 50 point change in score, the margin of error for the test. Further, knowing that is going to be the case, why keep taking a test and getting a poor score? Is that going to build confidence or the belief that a student will never succeed?
Another odd suggestion — only apply to schools that do not make you disclose every one of your SAT test scores, even those you told the SAT to hide. If a school is your dream or your perfect fit, why not still apply? Better yet, why not develop a test strategy that limits the number of times you take the test but shows improvement, which will look good to a college admissions officer?
Bottom line…the acting strategic in hiding scores will not mean anything if the scores never go way up. Plus, why build a college application around “hiding” and gamesmanship? Integrity is a critical value to learn at every stage in life, and we are not teaching integrity by moving away from full disclosure. I think the student who has the integrity and the courage and the honesty to tell me all of the scores and the story behind it would score more points in my admission matrix. In the end, colleges take real people, young men and women who can no longer hide behind screened applications, scores, grades. A pre-fab application will not show that human side that makes the difference. I am always shocked at how many students, parents and professionals underestimate the awareness and expertise of the college admissions officer.